Backlashes where the backlash is/was more irritating than the thing itself

Odradek

Seltzer and Friedberg

"The city itself is like a character"

Sympathizing with Holden Caulfeld

Megan Fox

Twilight(formerly)

Justin Bieber

Star Wars prequels

Section42L

John Green
Macklemore

Tre

Undertale.

Crystal

Agreed on all.

Sredni Vashtar

Obnoxious Homestuck fans, TGWTG, Lil B, "Stupid Hoe", Deadheads.

Section42L

My Little Pony
Steven Universe
RWBY

Bee

Baldanders said:

Seltzer and Friedberg

debatable

Odradek

No one was required by law to see those movies

Hexartes

Baldanders said:

"The city itself is like a character"

?

Odradek

I have seen multiple reviews where people talk about how good a setting is in something, and then immediately disavow the idea that they might ever say the city itself is like a character.