here I am, trying to look up good, wholesome crop rotation memes
Howdy, Stranger!
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
Comments
The liberal is from this picture which is described, and even sourced as, a recolored photo. I find that frankly unbelievable given how drawn it looks. I looked around a bit and hey
(from here) so that's... interesting. But let's say this photo is from the 1890s like it says, and depicts a peasant.
Now as far as I can tell feudalism in Ireland was, formally speaking at least, ended by the 1898 local government act, which transferred local power from appointed landlords to elected councils. But I think calling 19th century Ireland feudal is a bit dubious, not least because most of the terribleness was more due to the colonial situation.
So both of these are extremely late feudalism at best, and I feel this betrays the ahistoricity of the meme quite handily. Indeed, were I to make a similar meme, I would go for medieval feudalism. Medieval serfs of course violently rose up, all the time. Wikipedia lists at least a hundred revolts throughout world history major enough that even chroniclers extremely disinterested in the lives of peasants bothered to record them, and that's even if we exclude the revolts against e.g. the new Soviet system.
Also, I don't get "crop rotation" as a joke. Like, is that supposed to be unimportant? Sure, feudalism is the worst and ought to have been destroyed earlier, but improved food production is nothing to sneeze at. And novel crop rotation methods would indeed have been imposed by lords - not because they're smarter at agriculture than peasants or anything (haw) or care that peasants are starving, but because they had actual communications networks and wanted more stuff like usual. The most famous crop rotation pioneering, a four-crop rotation including turnips as allegorically depicted in Chinese propaganda cartoon Maoyuu Maou Yuusha, was indeed spread by some noble type dickhead. (It says "pioneered by farmers in the Waasland region" and I don't know if that means peasants and frankly I've spent way too much time on this stupid fucking meme anyway so I'm not going to research it, but it seems plausible.) It seems like the same kind of thing communists sometimes do now - "oh, your union negotiated you higher pensions? Why didn't you negotiate full communism?" except applied to feudalism, which is again, absolutely terrible, so it's more like "oh, you peasants asked for access to the granary to avoid having half your population rot in the streets after a bad harvest? Why didn't you negotiate full communism?" which I would also describe as terrible.
Anyway that stuff's boring. But I have good news!
(that last one isn't about crop rotation but i thought it was nice and sincere #wholesome)
(also yes multiple jokes about wind turbines, ag comics killing it)