You all have missed Hildebrand and Gufbrandr and Zulfiqar. Their names are "sword of battle", "God's sword", and "cleaver of spines", respectively. Yeah.
I find myself more interested in legendary items created by modern-day lore.
Such as the Vampire Killer, Gades's Sword, Reah's Harmonica, and such.
In fact, I'd like to see a story where the villains have already gathered all the old legendary weapons, such as Excalibur, Durandal, and Longinus's Spear, and the good guys have to create or find new legendary weapons to fight them.
Would Sting and Orcrist (and anything from Tolkien) count as newer or older legendary items?
For some reason I'm inclined to count Tolkien and Lovecraft stuff as older, but I'm not sure yet.
I think Discworld has some stuff and I think that might count as newer. At least I'm inclined to do so.
Man is a most complex simple creature: see what he weaves, and how base his reasons for doing so.
If you read Discworld, you'd know that's not true. It's a narrative rule; if the sword is nameless, grubby, and a bit nicked, it's hot shit and it'll never break. If the sword is jeweled, named, and has a lineage, it'll break the first time it's seen because it's funny that way.
And the Discworld works on narrative rules.
Carrot's sword absolutely does not count because it's the exact opposite of a legendary weapon. It's not pretty, it's not named, and you can put it in stone real well but you don't pull it out of a stone. It's just a really good sword.
But yeah, GMH's story idea makes me think of Fate/stay night, since Gilgamesh has the originals of every legendary weapon (You have Excalibur? That's nice, but I have Gram. That's the original Excalibur, you probably haven't heard of it.) and on the other hand Archer* fights entirely with copies of weapons (such as the many many Kanshou and Bakuya copies he loves).
*Gilgamesh is also Archer class but nobody calls him by it, while Archer's true identity is the king of Nasuverse spoilers that have already been spoiled to hell and back
If you read Discworld, you'd know that's not true. It's a narrative rule; if the sword is nameless, grubby, and a bit nicked, it's hot shit and it'll never break. If the sword is jeweled, named, and has a lineage, it'll break the first time it's seen because it's funny that way.
And the Discworld works on narrative rules.
Carrot's sword absolutely does not count because it's the exact opposite of a legendary weapon. It's not pretty, it's not named, and you can put it in stone real well but you don't pull it out of a stone. It's just a really good sword.
I said Carrot's sword might count because it was actually passed down from a king and because it's not just mundane, it's uniquely mundane.
*Gilgamesh is also Archer class but nobody calls him by it, while Archer's true identity is the king of Nasuverse spoilers that have already been spoiled to hell and back
I'd argue that Saber's identity is the king of Nasuverse spoilers, considering it's the one thing practically everyone who's heard of F/SN knows.
Zero's a bit different, though. I mean, we instantly know who Saber is there, too. The thing is, in-universe, revealing your identity early is a pretty terrible idea, since it also reveals, to some extent, what your abilities and weaknesses are. It would be like Achilles or Balder being a servant and then outright saying who they are.
Comments
Assassin poems, Poems that shoot
guns. Poems that wrestle cops into alleys
and take their weapons leaving them dead
(Stuck references, ahoy)
Such as the Vampire Killer, Gades's Sword, Reah's Harmonica, and such.
In fact, I'd like to see a story where the villains have already gathered all the old legendary weapons, such as Excalibur, Durandal, and Longinus's Spear, and the good guys have to create or find new legendary weapons to fight them.
Would Sting and Orcrist (and anything from Tolkien) count as newer or older legendary items?
For some reason I'm inclined to count Tolkien and Lovecraft stuff as older, but I'm not sure yet.
I think Discworld has some stuff and I think that might count as newer. At least I'm inclined to do so.
Although Carrot's sword might count.
☭ B̤̺͍̰͕̺̠̕u҉̖͙̝̮͕̲ͅm̟̼̦̠̹̙p͡s̹͖ ̻T́h̗̫͈̙̩r̮e̴̩̺̖̠̭̜ͅa̛̪̟͍̣͎͖̺d͉̦͠s͕̞͚̲͍ ̲̬̹̤Y̻̤̱o̭͠u̥͉̥̜͡ ̴̥̪D̳̲̳̤o̴͙̘͓̤̟̗͇n̰̗̞̼̳͙͖͢'҉͖t̳͓̣͍̗̰ ͉W̝̳͓̼͜a̗͉̳͖̘̮n͕ͅt͚̟͚ ̸̺T̜̖̖̺͎̱ͅo̭̪̰̼̥̜ ̼͍̟̝R̝̹̮̭ͅͅe̡̗͇a͍̘̤͉͘d̼̜ ⚢