Anime is a serious artform, and should be treated as such

Comments

• Sredni Vashtar

  2014-10-19 18:24:35

  “I'm surprised. Those clothes… but, aren't you…?”

  I know I'm going all "serious argument, dumb thread" here, but I really think that animation has received a bit of a short shrift as an art form until relatively recently, and as annoying as the weeb squad are, I can't say that they're technically wrong about anime having the potential to be high art. I just think that they're wrong about, well, basically everything else ever.
• Odradek

  2014-10-19 18:27:41

  My dreams exceed my real life

  Lord of the Game said:

  I know I'm going all "serious argument, dumb thread" here, but I really think that animation has received a bit of a short shrift as an art form until relatively recently, and as annoying as the weeb squad are, I can't say that they're technically wrong about anime having the potential to be high art. I just think that they're wrong about, well, basically everything else ever.

  I am bein' silly and the weeb squad are indeed right about this.

  
  Alternative response

  
  

  
• Anonus

  2014-10-19 18:27:58

  I've learned to tolerate drama...except on the boat

  I know animation is very, very broad, but it still seems like the American industry is dominated by jerks who see animation as nothing more than a vehicle for peddling things to children or as a medium for filler between Taco Bell ads aimed at college-aged males.
• Sredni Vashtar

  2014-10-19 18:30:52

  “I'm surprised. Those clothes… but, aren't you…?”

  El Kabong said:

  I know animation is very, very broad, but it still seems like the American industry is dominated by jerks who see animation as nothing more than a vehicle for peddling things to children or as a medium for filler between Taco Bell ads aimed at college-aged males.

  
  While there are exceptions, it does seem like the sitcom is the only sort of adult-targeted animation to thrive in North America that isn't an import product.
• Obā-san

  2014-10-19 18:32:44 edited 2014-10-19 18:32:53

  
  

  King of the Hill is easily one of the greatest shows in television history
  
• nohaynicklibre

  2014-10-19 18:33:34

  Smee, Maiman, Doktar, Pavelier, Button-Lee, Juan Ovyu

  Yep
• Yarrun XIX

  2014-10-19 18:47:52

  Whores! we want "poems that kill."
  Assassin poems, Poems that shoot
  guns. Poems that wrestle cops into alleys
  and take their weapons leaving them dead

  I do like KOTH's sense of realism.
• Yarrun XIX

  2014-10-19 18:48:40

  Whores! we want "poems that kill."
  Assassin poems, Poems that shoot
  guns. Poems that wrestle cops into alleys
  and take their weapons leaving them dead

  Which is funny because I usually hate it when animated shows are overly realistic. It makes me feel that they're not taking advantage of the medium.
• LW

  2014-10-19 22:04:11 edited 2014-10-19 22:06:56

  
  

  Lord of the Game said:

  I know I'm going all "serious argument, dumb thread" here, but I really think that animation has received a bit of a short shrift as an art form until relatively recently, and as annoying as the weeb squad are, I can't say that they're technically wrong about anime having the potential to be high art. I just think that they're wrong about, well, basically everything else ever.

  I definitely agree that animation has received a bit of a short shrift, especially in the West. Whether or not it has the potential to be "high art" is not a question I am qualified to answer, but I certainly would welcome more diversity in Western (and Eastern) animated shows. I think the animation age ghetto (to use a TVT term) problem that Anonus highlights is still an issue and I have my doubts about whether the existence of Adult Swim/Comedy Central animated stuff as a counterbalance to children's cartoons adequately addresses that problem.

  Skellett Skelletariat said:

  Which is funny because I usually hate it when animated shows are overly realistic. It makes me feel that they're not taking advantage of the medium.

  I think it just goes to show that animation is a means for telling a story just like any other means. I agree with the idea that certain types of shows (e.g., ones based on random or gag humor like Cromartie High School or Nichijou) are an especially good fit for that medium though.
  
• Anonus

  2014-10-19 22:17:33

  I've learned to tolerate drama...except on the boat

  I'm pretty sure the seasons of Space Ghost Coast to Coast that aired on the main Cartoon Network were more "adult" than most of what made its premiere on Adult Swim...