There's a headstone at the graveyard where the message carved is "in the name of all that is holy, we pray that the one buried here never returns to us". No-one but you seems to want to go near the grave.
One of the locals accidentally cuts himself on something, and you swear that he's bleeding...black blood. But when you try to look, everyone else nearby blocks your vision, as though doing so deliberately...
There has been alien sightings throughout the town, with resources like cattle, grain and bacon dwindling at a rapid pace. Some people have seen them, but most don't believe them. These people have disappeared, oddly enough, and in their place were letters saying "THEY KNEW TOO MUCH."
The Mayor's office building has a jail cell in it. Everyone assures you that it's just a relic of the town's history, but it looks like it's been used recently...
Remember back in the 50s when they'd record like Elvis singing YOU AIN'T NOTHIN BUT A HOUND DOG and then they'd turn the record over and reverse it and it was all NYERP NYERP NYERP NYERP NYERP and people were all like, "That is actually the voice of Satan coming from that song."
As you walk down the street, you pass by a window, and on the other side a tank full of iguanas. You notice that they seem to be staring at you sorrowfully, as if they want to tell you something.
(Probably more weird than creepy, but it's an idea that likes to pop into my head.)
Comments
^I'll do you one better.
There is no jail cell. Only a chair with handcuffs on it.