Note: I’ve only finished Episode 1 in its entirety and started on Episode 2, no untagged spoilers, please.
Even if we accept that there are supernatural elements, there must be something more to the locked-room puzzles than just “a witch did it”. Because, like, if it were that uninteresting, why would we even be here?
It doesn’t even necessarily have to be fair play, but there needs to be an “Ohhhh…yeah, that make sense…” moment, you know?